16. Open questions

State

A list of choices not yet made, not a to-do list. Collected from the node contract, the bootstrap plan and the multi-node build. Where the book assumes an answer, the page says so.

Decisions open

# Question Why it matters
1 The executor and the Docker socket. Accept the socket in a container (root-equivalent), a filtering proxy sidecar, a host service, or rootless Podman as the contract requires? The contract and the shipping bundle disagree
2 Does "desktop first" stand? Keeps the compositor and the manifest-kit resolver in scope
3 Keycloak's scope. Hosted deployments only, or household deployments too? Decides whether a household needs a local realm
4 The fourteen placement-authority amendments from the protocol and security reviews Several narrow the original position
5 The first audience for a one-node bundle The gateway source is private; publishing an image is a choice
6 Whether the distribution mechanism stays parked, and the nightly channel signing posture The plan currently says two contradictory things
7 Name clearance for BenixOS and DeviceNix before any public launch Only a surface-level search has been done
8 Venue's name. Provisional on purpose A rename touches one constant

Questions for the reviewers of the node contract

  1. "Unknown fails closed" versus "never block a local action." Security review recommends that local actions still require a valid cached grant.
  2. How far does the contract bind a standalone node with no registry on grant checks?
  3. Should the registry signing key be held by the owner's device or by the registry host? The contract forbids the owner key on the host, not the registry key.
  4. What is the root-of-trust provider interface for a host without a TPM?
  5. Which host profile counts as "supported" at the two-node milestone? Is a macOS node with no local IPC acceptable?
  6. Where do the conformance suites live: spec-kit, the Hearth repo, or the system monorepo?
  7. Does the agent's Hearth endpoint make fabric-kit a dependency of the agent crate, and is that acceptable?

Engineering questions

What this book assumes

Next

Glossary · About this book